Top 100 Starting Pitchers in Nostalgia Sim Baseball

Ranked by sim performance (not historical performance) on the criteria of simple ERA with an adjustment for offensive contributions at the plate.

  1. 1 Joe Wood

    IP 32,216 ERA: 2.84 Debut Year:

  2. 2 Bob Romby

    IP 9,675 ERA: 2.79 Debut Year:

  3. 3 Mark Fidrych

    IP 8,343 ERA: 2.89 Debut Year:

  4. 4 Ed Walsh

    IP 49,072 ERA: 2.86 Debut Year:

  5. 5 Babe Ruth

    IP 9,818 ERA: 3.00 Debut Year:

  6. 6 Dave Brown

    IP 10,335 ERA: 2.88 Debut Year:

  7. 7 Addie Joss

    IP 54,981 ERA: 2.84 Debut Year:

  8. 8 Charlie Sweeney

    IP 17,233 ERA: 2.95 Debut Year:

  9. 9 Walter Johnson

    IP 52,944 ERA: 2.98 Debut Year:

  10. 10 Jose Fernandez

    IP 13,007 ERA: 2.95 Debut Year:

  11. 11 José Leblanc

    IP 6,896 ERA: 2.88 Debut Year:

  12. 12 Satchel Paige

    IP 24,082 ERA: 2.99 Debut Year:

  13. 13 Clayton Kershaw

    IP 31,084 ERA: 3.03 Debut Year:

  14. 14 Sandy Koufax

    IP 45,854 ERA: 3.08 Debut Year:

  15. 15 Pedro Martinez

    IP 41,343 ERA: 3.08 Debut Year:

  16. 16 Tom Hughes

    IP 15,443 ERA: 3.14 Debut Year:

  17. 17 Mordecai Brown

    IP 53,222 ERA: 3.03 Debut Year:

  18. 18 Babe Adams

    IP 49,976 ERA: 3.10 Debut Year:

  19. 19 Jack Pfiester

    IP 36,736 ERA: 3.02 Debut Year:

  20. 20 Terry Larkin

    IP 8,587 ERA: 3.10 Debut Year:

  21. 21 Pete Alexander

    IP 47,535 ERA: 3.13 Debut Year:

  22. 22 Christy Mathewson

    IP 58,804 ERA: 3.07 Debut Year:

  23. 23 Ed Reulbach

    IP 52,671 ERA: 3.11 Debut Year:

  24. 24 Pete Conway

    IP 7,245 ERA: 3.04 Debut Year:

  25. 25 Carl Lundgren

    IP 27,683 ERA: 3.16 Debut Year:

  26. 26 Dupee Shaw

    IP 13,322 ERA: 3.16 Debut Year:

  27. 27 Whit Wyatt

    IP 23,328 ERA: 3.29 Debut Year:

  28. 28 Reb Russell

    IP 27,084 ERA: 3.17 Debut Year:

  29. 29 Max Manning

    IP 7,417 ERA: 3.18 Debut Year:

  30. 30 Matt Harvey

    IP 17,018 ERA: 3.26 Debut Year:

  31. 31 Randy Johnson

    IP 39,584 ERA: 3.25 Debut Year:

  32. 32 Greg Maddux

    IP 42,869 ERA: 3.22 Debut Year:

  33. 33 Noodles Hahn

    IP 45,037 ERA: 3.14 Debut Year:

  34. 34 Hilton Smith

    IP 8,635 ERA: 2.94 Debut Year:

  35. 35 Jake Arrieta

    IP 19,997 ERA: 3.23 Debut Year:

  36. 36 Orval Overall

    IP 44,057 ERA: 3.22 Debut Year:

  37. 37 Guy Morton

    IP 12,073 ERA: 3.32 Debut Year:

  38. 38 Sam Weaver

    IP 8,737 ERA: 3.22 Debut Year:

  39. 39 Spud Chandler

    IP 21,731 ERA: 3.24 Debut Year:

  40. 40 Carl Hubbell

    IP 36,523 ERA: 3.23 Debut Year:

  41. 41 Bill James

    IP 9,207 ERA: 3.29 Debut Year:

  42. 42 Buzz Capra

    IP 6,166 ERA: 3.16 Debut Year:

  43. 43 Fred Newman

    IP 7,370 ERA: 3.29 Debut Year:

  44. 44 Chief Bender

    IP 54,221 ERA: 3.22 Debut Year:

  45. 45 Cy Young

    IP 63,726 ERA: 3.19 Debut Year:

  46. 46 Lefty Grove

    IP 32,404 ERA: 3.29 Debut Year:

  47. 47 Alejandro Pena

    IP 10,022 ERA: 3.25 Debut Year:

  48. 48 Frank Smith

    IP 48,686 ERA: 3.27 Debut Year:

  49. 49 Andy Messersmith

    IP 29,430 ERA: 3.29 Debut Year:

  50. 50 Luis Severino

    IP 10,726 ERA: 3.31 Debut Year:

  51. 51 Bugs Raymond

    IP 23,217 ERA: 3.31 Debut Year:

  52. 52 Rube Foster

    IP 13,753 ERA: 3.34 Debut Year:

  53. 53 Dick Hughes

    IP 6,839 ERA: 3.31 Debut Year:

  54. 54 Rube Waddell

    IP 55,384 ERA: 3.17 Debut Year:

  55. 55 Johan Santana

    IP 36,261 ERA: 3.35 Debut Year:

  56. 56 Joe Benz

    IP 12,248 ERA: 3.23 Debut Year:

  57. 57 George McQuillan

    IP 25,657 ERA: 3.33 Debut Year:

  58. 58 Mort Cooper

    IP 32,626 ERA: 3.35 Debut Year:

  59. 59 Bobby Keefe

    IP 8,909 ERA: 3.33 Debut Year:

  60. 60 Ernie Shore

    IP 12,845 ERA: 3.37 Debut Year:

  61. 61 Norwood Gibson

    IP 15,277 ERA: 3.20 Debut Year:

  62. 62 Jeff Tesreau

    IP 27,063 ERA: 3.34 Debut Year:

  63. 63 Sid Fernandez

    IP 22,373 ERA: 3.35 Debut Year:

  64. 64 Floyd Youmans

    IP 6,101 ERA: 3.37 Debut Year:

  65. 65 Frank Owen

    IP 31,534 ERA: 3.30 Debut Year:

  66. 66 Fred Glade

    IP 18,805 ERA: 3.23 Debut Year:

  67. 67 Ed Karger

    IP 17,335 ERA: 3.35 Debut Year:

  68. 68 Tommy Bond

    IP 12,435 ERA: 3.39 Debut Year:

  69. 69 Juan Marichal

    IP 37,793 ERA: 3.30 Debut Year:

  70. 70 Steve Kline

    IP 7,268 ERA: 3.31 Debut Year:

  71. 71 Chris Sale

    IP 27,695 ERA: 3.32 Debut Year:

  72. 72 Roger Clemens

    IP 39,077 ERA: 3.32 Debut Year:

  73. 73 Jesse Flores

    IP 10,713 ERA: 3.45 Debut Year:

  74. 74 Deacon Phillippe

    IP 49,653 ERA: 3.27 Debut Year:

  75. 75 Ned Garvin

    IP 23,620 ERA: 3.42 Debut Year:

  76. 76 Larry Corcoran

    IP 8,548 ERA: 3.39 Debut Year:

  77. 77 Hal Newhouser

    IP 36,636 ERA: 3.38 Debut Year:

  78. 78 Dave Barnhill

    IP 8,995 ERA: 3.41 Debut Year:

  79. 79 Silver King

    IP 9,650 ERA: 3.78 Debut Year:

  80. 80 Ferdie Schupp

    IP 12,427 ERA: 3.34 Debut Year:

  81. 81 Nick Cullop

    IP 6,450 ERA: 3.27 Debut Year:

  82. 82 Roy Halladay

    IP 41,077 ERA: 3.37 Debut Year:

  83. 83 Harry Coveleski

    IP 27,892 ERA: 3.39 Debut Year:

  84. 84 George Bradley

    IP 12,031 ERA: 3.40 Debut Year:

  85. 85 Hippo Vaughn

    IP 41,380 ERA: 3.43 Debut Year:

  86. 86 Butch Wensloff

    IP 6,122 ERA: 3.20 Debut Year:

  87. 87 Jake Weimer

    IP 45,154 ERA: 3.34 Debut Year:

  88. 88 Bill Bernhard

    IP 15,984 ERA: 3.23 Debut Year:

  89. 89 Amos Rusie

    IP 32,472 ERA: 3.42 Debut Year:

  90. 90 Chet Brewer

    IP 6,346 ERA: 3.43 Debut Year:

  91. 91 Tom Seaver

    IP 39,037 ERA: 3.38 Debut Year:

  92. 92 Rube Vickers

    IP 7,653 ERA: 3.46 Debut Year:

  93. 93 Dazzy Vance

    IP 30,378 ERA: 3.40 Debut Year:

  94. 94 Ed Summers

    IP 18,324 ERA: 3.43 Debut Year:

  95. 95 Garrett Richards

    IP 10,380 ERA: 3.43 Debut Year:

  96. 96 Buck O'Brien

    IP 7,278 ERA: 3.39 Debut Year:

  97. 97 Jim McCormick

    IP 14,601 ERA: 3.41 Debut Year:

  98. 98 Bob Gibson

    IP 33,706 ERA: 3.46 Debut Year:

  99. 99 Hugh Bedient

    IP 7,314 ERA: 3.44 Debut Year:

  100. 100 Howie Camnitz

    IP 41,141 ERA: 3.42 Debut Year:

Top 100 Pitchers · Updated 2025-10-17 02:10:16

Top 100 Pitchers
Top 100 Starting Pitchers in Nostalgia Sim Baseball.