Top 100 Hitters in Nostalgia Sim Baseball

Ranked by sim performance (not historical performance) on the criteria of runs created per plate appearance (PA).

  1. 1 Charlie Smith

    PA 14,213 Sim Career Slash: .375/.466/.602 Debut Year: 1925
  2. 2 Josh Gibson

    PA 54,084 Sim Career Slash: .340/.420/.629 Debut Year: 1930
  3. 3 Babe Ruth

    PA 100,479 Sim Career Slash: .324/.457/.597 Debut Year: 1914
  4. 4 Todd Haney

    PA 1,720 Sim Career Slash: .401/.453/.594 Debut Year: 1992
  5. 5 Ted Williams

    PA 95,526 Sim Career Slash: .329/.453/.560 Debut Year: 1939
  6. 6 Buck Leonard

    PA 43,471 Sim Career Slash: .322/.430/.539 Debut Year: 1934
  7. 7 Ross Barnes

    PA 32,920 Sim Career Slash: .344/.405/.477 Debut Year: 1871
  8. 8 Mule Suttles

    PA 29,968 Sim Career Slash: .322/.389/.584 Debut Year: 1924
  9. 9 Rogers Hornsby

    PA 116,383 Sim Career Slash: .340/.421/.545 Debut Year: 1915
  10. 10 Barry Bonds

    PA 110,283 Sim Career Slash: .295/.428/.554 Debut Year: 1986
  11. 11 Oscar Charleston

    PA 62,387 Sim Career Slash: .336/.423/.543 Debut Year: 1915
  12. 12 Lou Gehrig

    PA 78,030 Sim Career Slash: .318/.418/.541 Debut Year: 1923
  13. 13 Turkey Stearnes

    PA 26,676 Sim Career Slash: .323/.399/.542 Debut Year: 1923
  14. 14 Cristóbal Torriente

    PA 32,976 Sim Career Slash: .331/.425/.510 Debut Year: 1913
  15. 15 Mickey Mantle

    PA 93,458 Sim Career Slash: .295/.401/.537 Debut Year: 1951
  16. 16 Jimmie Foxx

    PA 89,508 Sim Career Slash: .303/.401/.545 Debut Year: 1925
  17. 17 Mike Trout

    PA 89,686 Sim Career Slash: .294/.401/.515 Debut Year: 2011
  18. 18 Frank Thomas

    PA 116,265 Sim Career Slash: .304/.421/.525 Debut Year: 1990
  19. 19 Jud Wilson

    PA 25,369 Sim Career Slash: .328/.412/.498 Debut Year: 1923
  20. 20 Joe Jackson

    PA 112,848 Sim Career Slash: .342/.405/.485 Debut Year: 1908
  21. 21 Ted Strong

    PA 24,044 Sim Career Slash: .320/.415/.487 Debut Year: 1937
  22. 22 Ty Cobb

    PA 121,283 Sim Career Slash: .348/.410/.472 Debut Year: 1905
  23. 23 Heavy Johnson

    PA 41,152 Sim Career Slash: .331/.390/.520 Debut Year: 1920
  24. 24 Showboat Fisher

    PA 3,555 Sim Career Slash: .337/.394/.503 Debut Year: 1923
  25. 25 Billy Hamilton

    PA 106,934 Sim Career Slash: .330/.436/.426 Debut Year: 1888
  26. 26 Joe DiMaggio

    PA 77,305 Sim Career Slash: .308/.374/.523 Debut Year: 1936
  27. 27 Stan Musial

    PA 108,241 Sim Career Slash: .318/.397/.503 Debut Year: 1941
  28. 28 Ed Delahanty

    PA 122,612 Sim Career Slash: .335/.401/.483 Debut Year: 1888
  29. 29 Ed Steele

    PA 8,872 Sim Career Slash: .318/.417/.482 Debut Year: 1942
  30. 30 Cody Bellinger

    PA 16,523 Sim Career Slash: .285/.374/.516 Debut Year: 2017
  31. 31 Marvin Williams

    PA 11,338 Sim Career Slash: .317/.370/.494 Debut Year: 1943
  32. 32 Sam Thompson

    PA 83,719 Sim Career Slash: .335/.388/.498 Debut Year: 1885
  33. 33 John Beckwith

    PA 22,030 Sim Career Slash: .316/.369/.527 Debut Year: 1920
  34. 34 Dan Brouthers

    PA 87,156 Sim Career Slash: .322/.410/.474 Debut Year: 1879
  35. 35 Willie Mays

    PA 88,892 Sim Career Slash: .295/.373/.513 Debut Year: 1948
  36. 36 Lefty O'Doul

    PA 61,066 Sim Career Slash: .334/.400/.477 Debut Year: 1919
  37. 37 Hank Greenberg

    PA 80,102 Sim Career Slash: .291/.377/.524 Debut Year: 1930
  38. 38 Tris Speaker

    PA 113,124 Sim Career Slash: .325/.401/.452 Debut Year: 1907
  39. 39 Fernando Tatis

    PA 3,465 Sim Career Slash: .297/.354/.526 Debut Year: 2019
  40. 40 Henry Aaron

    PA 93,508 Sim Career Slash: .304/.369/.521 Debut Year: 1954
  41. 41 Babe Melton

    PA 6,625 Sim Career Slash: .303/.346/.499 Debut Year: 1926
  42. 42 Mel Ott

    PA 85,136 Sim Career Slash: .291/.399/.466 Debut Year: 1926
  43. 43 Manny Ramirez

    PA 100,537 Sim Career Slash: .294/.388/.523 Debut Year: 1993
  44. 44 Edgar Wesley

    PA 22,967 Sim Career Slash: .307/.384/.492 Debut Year: 1920
  45. 45 Lance Berkman

    PA 76,593 Sim Career Slash: .290/.388/.502 Debut Year: 1999
  46. 46 Albert Pujols

    PA 84,828 Sim Career Slash: .302/.381/.527 Debut Year: 2001
  47. 47 Charlie Blackwell

    PA 14,721 Sim Career Slash: .307/.400/.468 Debut Year: 1920
  48. 48 Kevin Mitchell

    PA 47,517 Sim Career Slash: .289/.383/.517 Debut Year: 1984
  49. 49 Kyle Tucker

    PA 3,160 Sim Career Slash: .286/.371/.510 Debut Year: 2018
  50. 50 George Hall

    PA 8,607 Sim Career Slash: .316/.360/.464 Debut Year: 1871
  51. 51 Johnny Mize

    PA 61,994 Sim Career Slash: .299/.380/.487 Debut Year: 1936
  52. 52 Joey Votto

    PA 81,297 Sim Career Slash: .301/.405/.466 Debut Year: 2007
  53. 53 Dobie Moore

    PA 27,027 Sim Career Slash: .313/.359/.466 Debut Year: 1920
  54. 54 Frank Robinson

    PA 94,668 Sim Career Slash: .293/.381/.510 Debut Year: 1956
  55. 55 Alejandro Oms

    PA 12,515 Sim Career Slash: .307/.388/.481 Debut Year: 1923
  56. 56 Willard Brown

    PA 19,200 Sim Career Slash: .320/.366/.500 Debut Year: 1935
  57. 57 Jason Giambi

    PA 99,991 Sim Career Slash: .284/.408/.477 Debut Year: 1995
  58. 58 Hack Wilson

    PA 56,443 Sim Career Slash: .289/.375/.507 Debut Year: 1923
  59. 59 Aaron Judge

    PA 37,107 Sim Career Slash: .268/.390/.485 Debut Year: 2016
  60. 60 Ray Grimes

    PA 21,771 Sim Career Slash: .312/.400/.452 Debut Year: 1920
  61. 61 John McGraw

    PA 134,654 Sim Career Slash: .320/.433/.400 Debut Year: 1891
  62. 62 Jimmy Wood

    PA 5,232 Sim Career Slash: .304/.375/.450 Debut Year: 1871
  63. 63 Larry Walker

    PA 81,088 Sim Career Slash: .298/.382/.485 Debut Year: 1989
  64. 64 Artie Wilson

    PA 13,322 Sim Career Slash: .332/.406/.425 Debut Year: 1944
  65. 65 Jackie Robinson

    PA 80,866 Sim Career Slash: .305/.388/.451 Debut Year: 1945
  66. 66 Gary Sheffield

    PA 67,454 Sim Career Slash: .291/.386/.493 Debut Year: 1988
  67. 67 Willie Wells

    PA 46,381 Sim Career Slash: .300/.377/.488 Debut Year: 1924
  68. 68 Jesse Burkett

    PA 121,878 Sim Career Slash: .324/.403/.426 Debut Year: 1890
  69. 69 Al Simmons

    PA 75,206 Sim Career Slash: .320/.365/.487 Debut Year: 1924
  70. 70 Mark McGwire

    PA 88,262 Sim Career Slash: .254/.379/.517 Debut Year: 1986
  71. 71 Brian Giles

    PA 95,578 Sim Career Slash: .287/.396/.467 Debut Year: 1995
  72. 72 Juan Soto

    PA 22,869 Sim Career Slash: .279/.392/.470 Debut Year: 2018
  73. 73 Harry Heilmann

    PA 95,208 Sim Career Slash: .318/.387/.471 Debut Year: 1914
  74. 74 Mike Piazza

    PA 83,670 Sim Career Slash: .299/.365/.520 Debut Year: 1992
  75. 75 Minnie Miñoso

    PA 5,287 Sim Career Slash: .305/.365/.466 Debut Year: 1946
  76. 76 Jeff Bagwell

    PA 93,260 Sim Career Slash: .283/.389/.492 Debut Year: 1991
  77. 77 Arky Vaughan

    PA 89,529 Sim Career Slash: .300/.387/.428 Debut Year: 1932
  78. 78 Luis Arraez

    PA 8,592 Sim Career Slash: .322/.387/.431 Debut Year: 2019
  79. 79 Halley Harding

    PA 2,568 Sim Career Slash: .309/.387/.424 Debut Year: 1926
  80. 80 Miguel Cabrera

    PA 64,623 Sim Career Slash: .307/.378/.514 Debut Year: 2003
  81. 81 Merv Rettenmund

    PA 18,643 Sim Career Slash: .293/.398/.430 Debut Year: 1968
  82. 82 Charlie Keller

    PA 73,751 Sim Career Slash: .275/.383/.453 Debut Year: 1939
  83. 83 Dick Lundy

    PA 13,561 Sim Career Slash: .313/.381/.459 Debut Year: 1920
  84. 84 Mookie Betts

    PA 57,012 Sim Career Slash: .290/.363/.474 Debut Year: 2014
  85. 85 Babe Herman

    PA 80,565 Sim Career Slash: .309/.372/.480 Debut Year: 1926
  86. 86 Honus Wagner

    PA 128,448 Sim Career Slash: .317/.383/.449 Debut Year: 1897
  87. 87 Todd Helton

    PA 112,267 Sim Career Slash: .301/.394/.463 Debut Year: 1997
  88. 88 Larry Doby

    PA 66,206 Sim Career Slash: .284/.376/.452 Debut Year: 1942
  89. 89 Tip O'Neill

    PA 23,230 Sim Career Slash: .308/.370/.432 Debut Year: 1883
  90. 90 Eddie Mathews

    PA 85,818 Sim Career Slash: .274/.381/.475 Debut Year: 1952
  91. 91 Pedro Guerrero

    PA 62,078 Sim Career Slash: .296/.374/.485 Debut Year: 1978
  92. 92 Dick Allen

    PA 69,681 Sim Career Slash: .289/.371/.489 Debut Year: 1963
  93. 93 George Brett

    PA 74,817 Sim Career Slash: .303/.365/.469 Debut Year: 1973
  94. 94 Tetelo Vargas

    PA 8,883 Sim Career Slash: .318/.385/.435 Debut Year: 1927
  95. 95 Paul Waner

    PA 89,860 Sim Career Slash: .318/.388/.444 Debut Year: 1926
  96. 96 Valentín Dreke

    PA 12,491 Sim Career Slash: .321/.385/.432 Debut Year: 1920
  97. 97 Doc Dudley

    PA 2,506 Sim Career Slash: .319/.396/.456 Debut Year: 1920
  98. 98 Biz Mackey

    PA 44,868 Sim Career Slash: .313/.386/.448 Debut Year: 1920
  99. 99 Mike Smith

    PA 91,583 Sim Career Slash: .308/.391/.428 Debut Year: 1886
  100. 100 Ben Taylor

    PA 10,647 Sim Career Slash: .325/.391/.446 Debut Year: 1912

Top 100 Hitters · Updated 2025-10-17 02:10:16

Top 100 Hitters
Top 100 Hitters in Nostalgia Sim Baseball.